Funny how a lot of improvement opportunities when analyzed lead back to the basics - incident management process.
Started out with examination of KPIs because new boss wanted the KPIs. Right or wrong he wanted the KPIs in the areas of availability, capacity and resource management. Fine. The more we talked about what our KPIs should be and how they are to be implemented, the more we kept coming back to poor practices (or lack of certain practices altogether) related to Incident management.
For the KPIs identified for avail and cap Incident would be the first stop to collect the right data, to have that we need proper procedures, roles and tools in place. In the end - new project, IM process

Aaaah... I have been vindicated. My nagging about analyzing what we've got first instead of diving head first into KPIs in the areas that we didn't even know why we were touching to begin with has finally paid off. While there is no denying avail and cap are important to this organization, however, there are more pressing underlying areas to deal with.
The crap part is that now I am given a PM hat.
